Advice please on this guarantor mess
6 girls (including my friends daughter) signed a contract on a house last year, then before moving in 2 girls dropped out. One found a replacement but one (Miss x) did not. When the remaining girls came to pick up the keys, the letting agents told them they would have to cover Miss X’s share of the deposit, worth £250. At the time, the letting agent taking the money apparently made a note of the names of those who had paid this money but the agent now denies this.
In March, a new tenant moved into the room left vacant by Miss x, and paid the agents his £250 deposit to do so. Given that he was technically replacing Miss x in the flat the agent paid the deposit back to Miss x although in fact she had never paid one. The other tenants then asked Miss x to return this money to them as they had paid in her name and the agents had allowed them to expect it to be given directly back to them.
Miss x has refused to return the deposit to the other girls and the letting agents say they have acted legally, leaving the 4 girls out of pocket. Putting the moral issues aside are the girls in any position to get their deposit back?
Want to read more?
This is a members only forum, if you want to read more you need to login to your membership, if you are not a member, click here to join.